Joshua Wood
Andrew AtkinsonOğulcan Girginç
2 likes and reposts
  • @danhulton I don’t think this book is about GitHub Copilot. 🙂

  • @wood I mean it is and it isn't. Obviously it's not LITERALLY about Copilot. But I'm mainly offering that as an example of what was considered to be a slam-dunk example of LLM-augmented applications, and how it didn't really turn out.

    Most developers who use an LLM tool in their code editors notice a significant speed up and report a pretty high level of satisfaction, so, easy win, right? But studies are cautioning that devs are turning in worse code, just faster. (1/5)

  • And it's not like the developers of these tools aren't any good at using them - there are multiple competing LLM coding assistants out there and they all suffer similar issues. (2/5)

  • So ultimately, I'm concerned about any of application that introduces AI augmentation. I think the actual, practical applications of LLMs are going to be more limited than they were originally advertised as, and a lot of existing applications and tasks that expect firm and factual inputs are just not going to be improved by their addition. (3/5)

  • Which isn't to say there's no point learning how to use them or in reading the book! I just think it's likely going to be more akin to learning a highly specialized skill, like physics programming, as opposed to a general "level up" skill. (4/5)

  • Which is likely WAAAY off topic from what you were originally taking about, which is likely as simple as wanting to level up your skill in using these tools, but I didn't want you to think I was drive-by insulting your choice, I just realized I had a longer point I was trying to make that I poorly explained with my original, light-hearted, and incomplete post. (5/5)

Want to opt out?